bright_lilim ([info]bright_lilim) wrote,
@ 2008-04-04 20:26:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Why I read Lois McMaster Bujold
I'm a long-time fan of Ms Bujold and especially a fan of her Vorkosigan science fiction series. This book is either the first one or a prequel to the "actual" series, depending on who you ask. This and the next book, Barrayar, are my favorite ones in the whole series.



The reasons I continue to read Ms Bujold are her vivid characters and settings, her ability to write character-driven plots, and her beautiful use of language. But what first attracted me to read her was that her books are female-friendly. That is, the women characters are there and so are their strengths and weaknesses. They are not just prototypes representing half of humanity simply because of their sex. Their needs are addressed by the society by whatever degree is possible. This is not a common thing in sci-fi.

Quite a few sci-fi settings are centered squarely on males and their needs. Want to legalize prostitution? Create android sex-partners? (Which, by the way, I consider to be just as insulting to men as to women.) Have a male-only soldier story? A war story where women are fit to be only as victims? Ignore women in society altogether? I've read dozens of these and I had the distinct feeling that I, a woman, was not wanted as a reader or a buyer. That I was encroaching on a man's world where there's no place for women at all or at most as mothers and brainless sex-kittens and victims. This sort of picture of the future horrifies me. Because I'm here and I damned well want to be part of the future and not as a side-liner!

Was is any wonder that I stopped reading science fiction and read fantasy and mystery instead? (Not that they're much better. But at least with them there's the excuse that the writers have a limited technology to use.)

And then along came Shards of Honor. Which had a strong female lead who was not a victim but herself and more importantly, a leader of other people, including males. She was in control of her life, her body, and her future.

Then I read about Beta Colony with its reproductive implants and uterine replicators. Wow! No more "high tech" societies where human fertility seems to be the only thing that isn't controlled. Or rather the writer hasn't even though about its importance and impact on the society and the characters because to him it's a non-issue. And a democracy to boot. That's also pretty rare in sci-fi.

You can probably imagine my disappointment when the overwhelming majority of the books are set in the patriarchal and backwater little Barrayar. Instead of exploring the interesting social mores the Beta Colony must have, we are given once again the tired old "women are second-class citizens and must be either a virgin or a whore" and "women's place is at home". Yes, it's important to write about these things but... that's the fight we are still fighting in the real world. I just sometimes need a break from that.

And if we can't even imagine a world without these old attitudes, how can we create one in the real world?

Still I continue to read Bujold. She has very good ideas, interesting characters, and good plotting. And variety. There.s no chance of anyone mixing up her books.




(Post a new comment)


[info]countrycousin
2008-04-04 06:05 pm UTC (link)
I view the stories out of Barrayar as, in addition to providing some military adventure tales in an SF setting (which sells), provide an environment where there exist societies without these particular problems (but Cordelia is careful to admit that Beta has other problems and, in fact, she ran smack into some of them) and there exist societies that have much worse problems (Jacksons Whole). Part of the fun of the Vorkosigan stories is watching the steps being taken. I suspect the steps we see are unrealistically large, but that's OK - realism I get enough of. :<)

(Reply to this)

Beta Colony has its problems too, of course.
[info]dakiwiboid
2008-04-04 06:07 pm UTC (link)
Think of the way Cordelia is treated when she returns after the war and they don't know how to handle her. If you don't conform to their paradigm, it's still not a good way to live.

(Reply to this) (Thread)

Re: Beta Colony has its problems too, of course.
[info]bright_lilim
2008-04-04 07:16 pm UTC (link)
Of course, but they are a different set of problems and not the same old, same old I've read (and experienced) a hundered times over.

And what if I wanted to conform? I don't want any kids, so I have no problem with that limit, for example. The therapy treatment is a different thing but I suspect it's not very common. I saw no indication that anyone wanted to force people to stay in Beta if they wanted to move and weren't suspected of being enemy spies.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]troubleinchina
2008-04-04 06:37 pm UTC (link)
I always feel so bad when Bujold comes up. I'm happy to recommend her to people, but her books just do nothing for me. *sigh*

Ah well - I know lots of cool people love her, and thus, I rec! And then more people love her! Win for everyone!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]bright_lilim
2008-04-04 07:17 pm UTC (link)
Yup! I also know some books I should like but just don't.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…